Gnosis Token Revocation Fails With WalletConnect

Hey guys! Ever tried to revoke a token on Gnosis using WalletConnect and found yourself staring at a spinning confirm button that just… won't? Yeah, you're not alone. This is a pretty frustrating issue, and we're gonna dive deep into it, exploring the problem, the details, and what needs to be fixed. Let's get started!

The Problem: Revoke.cash and the Gnosis Safe Glitch

So, the core issue is this: When you try to revoke a token on Gnosis using WalletConnect via revoke.cash, the action doesn't complete. The confirm button just keeps spinning, leaving you hanging. This means you can't effectively manage your token approvals on Gnosis Safe, which is a big deal for anyone using the platform for secure asset management. Think of it like trying to lock your front door, but the lock just keeps turning without actually securing the door. Not cool, right?

This problem specifically affects users attempting to interact with their tokens on Gnosis while connected via WalletConnect. Revoke.cash is the tool many use to manage token approvals, and it's a super handy tool. When it breaks, it’s a big problem. The issue makes it impossible to revoke the tokens because it fails to execute the transaction, leaving your tokens vulnerable. This prevents users from properly managing their token approvals within the Gnosis Safe environment. The result is users being unable to secure their digital assets within their Gnosis Safe wallets, leading to increased exposure to security risks. The core functionality of Gnosis Safe relies on this, and when it breaks it makes the entire experience quite frustrating and, let's face it, a little scary.

Basically, the confirm button gets stuck in an infinite loop, never actually submitting the transaction to the blockchain. This prevents users from revoking permissions. This is a classic case of a UI/UX problem combined with an underlying technical issue preventing the transaction from going through. It can be due to various reasons, such as incompatibility between WalletConnect and Gnosis Safe, issues with the transaction execution on the Gnosis chain itself, or problems with how revoke.cash interacts with both. The consequences are pretty significant, as users are left with no way to revoke token approvals and potentially expose their funds to risk. This means you might be stuck with approvals you don’t want, leaving your assets vulnerable. It's like having a leaky faucet – eventually, it’ll cause a flood.

Why This Matters

It matters because Gnosis Safe is all about security. Being able to revoke token approvals is a key part of that security. Without it, you're essentially leaving the door open to potential exploits. If you've ever had a bad experience, you understand how critical it is.

Deep Dive into the Issue: References and Details

Let's get into the nitty-gritty. The core of the problem revolves around the interaction between WalletConnect, revoke.cash, and Gnosis Safe. The specific behavior involves the transaction initiation failing to complete. This is the main reason why the confirm button just keeps spinning. To get a clearer understanding, we have a link to a jam.dev report. The jam.dev report provides a detailed breakdown of the issue, which includes the error messages, the steps taken, and the results. This is crucial for developers to investigate the issue further and implement a fix.

There may be several underlying causes for this behavior. One could be a compatibility problem between the specific versions of WalletConnect and the Gnosis Safe contracts. Another possibility is an error with how revoke.cash interacts with the Gnosis Safe's transaction processing. Another likely source for the problem may be the wallet itself. The wallet may have an issue with handling the transaction. It's critical to note the specific version numbers of each component to accurately diagnose the problem. The jam.dev report often includes this information, allowing the developers to test different scenarios and identify the problem. The provided image shows the state of the confirm button, which is the exact problem we’re talking about. The spinning button is a signal that something is wrong. The user is left in a state of uncertainty, unsure whether the transaction is processing or failing. This behavior can lead to increased frustration and loss of trust in the platform. It's often difficult for the user to understand what's happening behind the scenes, so the UI should provide better feedback on the progress of the transaction, and any errors that occur during the process.

What's happening in the background

In a normal transaction process: The user initiates a transaction to revoke a token approval. Then, the wallet signs the transaction. After that, the signed transaction is submitted to the blockchain. However, in this case, one of these steps is failing. The transaction may never get submitted because the wallet is not signing the transaction, or the transaction may be malformed or invalid when it is submitted to the blockchain. If the transaction fails, the user needs to know why it failed, whether because of gas limits, network problems, or other errors. Any of these problems could explain the spinning confirm button.

Acceptance Criteria: What Needs to Happen

So, what's the ultimate goal? What needs to be fixed so that users can revoke their tokens on Gnosis safely and securely via WalletConnect? Simple:

Revoking tokens on Gnosis while connected by WalletConnect should work.

This means that when a user initiates a token revocation, the transaction should be successfully submitted to the blockchain, and the token approval should be revoked. The spinning confirm button should go away, and a success message, or error message, should be displayed to the user.

Here's a more detailed breakdown of the acceptance criteria:

• The user should be able to connect to their Gnosis Safe wallet using WalletConnect. This is fundamental.
• The user should be able to initiate a token revocation through revoke.cash. This includes the app correctly identifying the approved tokens and presenting them for revocation.
• The user should be prompted to confirm the transaction in their wallet, as expected.
• The wallet should successfully sign and submit the transaction. This is the most critical step.
• The transaction should be successfully executed on the blockchain. This means the token approval is revoked.
• The user should receive feedback on the status of the transaction. A success message should appear if the transaction succeeds, or an error message if the transaction fails.

To achieve these goals, developers will need to identify the root cause of the spinning confirm button issue. They may need to look at the compatibility between WalletConnect and Gnosis Safe, the interaction between revoke.cash and the Gnosis Safe contracts, or if there's any network or gas limit problem. Developers may also need to do thorough testing to ensure that the fix works correctly, and that users can safely revoke tokens. Then they can release updates for the relevant components, which include WalletConnect, revoke.cash, or Gnosis Safe itself.

The Importance of a Working Solution

When this problem is fixed, it will provide peace of mind to the users, and allow the community to safely manage their assets. This will also boost the reputation of the Gnosis Safe and WalletConnect. The reliability of this is critical for users to trust their wallets.

Troubleshooting and Possible Workarounds

Okay, so while we're waiting for a fix, what can you do? Here are some possible workarounds (use with caution!):

• Try a different browser or device: Sometimes, browser extensions or device configurations can interfere with WalletConnect. Try a different browser or device to see if that helps.
• Check your WalletConnect connection: Make sure your wallet is properly connected to revoke.cash and that there are no connection errors. Refresh the connection or reconnect if needed.
• Contact support: Reach out to the Gnosis Safe or WalletConnect support teams. They may have insights into the problem or potential workarounds.
• Use another method: If possible, try revoking the token approval through another method, such as directly through the Gnosis Safe interface or another wallet.

Remember, these are just potential workarounds, and they may not always work. It's always best to wait for an official fix to ensure your assets are protected.

Conclusion: Looking Ahead

So, to sum it up: The inability to revoke tokens on Gnosis via WalletConnect is a real issue, making the confirmation button spin endlessly. While this spinning can be frustrating, the acceptance criteria are clear: Token revocation should work flawlessly through Gnosis Safe with WalletConnect, and the issue needs to be addressed so people can feel confident using the platforms. Let's hope the developers fix this problem and deliver a safe and reliable solution for all of us. Until then, stay safe out there, and make sure to always double-check those approvals!

I hope this helps! If you encounter any similar issues, feel free to share and let's work on fixing this. Feel free to leave a comment!